By Pat Coleman
GRAND CHUTE, Wis. -- Andersen Gardner was a Cortland State win away from being a slam-dunk choice for Most Outstanding Player of the 2010 Division III baseball championships. But a few years ago, he was seemingly destined for a different path: not just a different school, but a different level of baseball altogether.
"It's been life-changing," Gardner said in the postgame news conference following his team's 17-5 loss to Illinois Wesleyan. "I didn't really know what I was going to do coming out of high school because I'm not really the smartest guy. I had a couple of D-I offers, and I'm glad I turned them down because my career here has just been unbelievable.
"To go to three World Series out of four -- some people don't even get to one in four years. It's been one heck of a ride. It's just sad it didn't happen the way we wanted it to, but national runner-up is still pretty good out of however many colleges there are in D-III."
Gardner's performance in the second round game against Linfield caused a buzz in the stands, with fans talking about staying in their seats just to see "that designated hitter" come up for a third time after hitting homers in his first two at-bats. He finished the week batting .500 with four homers, a triple and a double. He was walked five times, including once with the bases loaded by Linfield in the Tuesday elimination game. Consindering he entered Tuesday with a 1.500 slugging percentage, perhaps the walk was the best alternative. Gardner was also hit by pitch three times.
BEST FINISH EVER: This was Cortland State's 10th trip to the Division III World Series and the Red Dragons will go back home to New York without a title once again. But this was as far as they had gotten, to the winner-take-all game. The Red Dragons had played on the final day before, losing to UW-Whitewater in 2005 in the first game when needing to beat the Warhawks twice. Under the old format, UW-Whitewater had gotten Monday off and come in fresh on Tuesday.
Coach Joe Brown has been at Cortland for all 10 trips. "I told all the returners to watch (the Illinois Wesleyan celebration), that this is an expectation we have here. It's not some far-fetched imagination. It's a realistic objective and goal. We've been extremely fortunate at Cortland to be at the World Series 10 times, and when these young men get home they'll start working on next year."
The 10 appearances at the championships are the most for any team without a national championship. Second is Carthage, with seven.
WHERE'D THAT COME FROM? A year ago, Kyle Scallion was a mop-up reliever for the Shenandoah Hornets. This time around in Appleton, he was an All-Region performer as Shenandoah's closer.

Scallion throws with a motion somewhere in between sidearm and a true submariner, and the ball ends up coming at the hitter from a point about six inches off the ground. And with a pseudo-submariner, even more than for other pitchers, the arm angle can be tough to find. You can see an example in the Larry Radloff-shot photo at left.
"It normally takes about two years for a young man to find an arm slot where he's comfortable," said Shenandoah coach Kevin Anderson. "This is year No. 3 for Kyle, and he's worked extremely hard to find that and he's been big for us all year. We've been very lucky or fortunate in my career to have some pretty good sidearm/submarine guys. Some guys are true submariners and some are sidearmers, and he's really in between that. The ball's coming off the ground about six inches."
Scallion came into Saturday's game against Johns Hopkins in the sixth inning, with runners on first and second and nobody out. He got out of that jam, but eventually gave up seven runs in the eighth, five of them earned.
"We did not think we would score any more runs," said Anderson, "so we treated it like a 2-0 baseball game and the matchup was right for Scallion after the hit by pitch and the walk.
"What we were doing was trying to coach to not let them get a run, because we didn't think we would score any more because (JHU starter Sam Eagleson) was baffling us. If we had to do it over again we'd do it the exact same way."
NOT FILAK: Jason Pankau delivered a great performance, but if Division III's gold standard this year is Oneonta State ace Dave Filak, the Cortland State batters who have faced both say Pankau isn't quite there.
"I wouldn't say he's in the (same) league as Filak is but he mixes up his pitches pretty well," said Cortland State third baseman Steve Nickel. "He's got a little life to his fastball. He's got a pretty good changeup."
"Giving two runs back allowed Pankau to have some room for error and allow him to work the plate a little bit more," Cortland coach Joe Brown added.
Still, that's nothing against Pankau. After all, Filak is being talked about as a draft pick in the sixth- to tenth-round neighborhood. He had a 2.00 ERA with 104 strikeouts and just 19 walks in 67-1/3 innings, allowing just 41 hits. Against Cortland on May 7, Filark threw a complete-game three-hitter, striking out 10. Conversely, Cortland scored 71 runs in six games at the Division III World Series.
WHAT THEY SAID: Unlike at other Division III championships D3sports.com has covered, the Division III baseball committee doesn't come out and talk much. They pretty much stay sequestered in their luxury box, often with the door closed. But every once in a while we would run into a committee member on the concourse or on the field between games and one of the things which came up was the concept of using a little imagination in building the regionals.
Although for the most part the committee kept teams in their "home" regionals -- putting teams in a tournament with other teams from their region, whether it makes for a competitively balanced bracket or not, regardless of whether there are other regionals they can bus to conveniently, they did make one change that we had in our projections. That was to send Penn State-Behrend to the Mideast, instead of busing them all the way across Pennsylvania to the Mid-Atlantic Regional. We recognized that it was a much shorter trip when building our mock brackets, and Behrend had a little success this year where in the past they have taken a longer trip and struggled.
There's room for using the 500-mile busing rule to spread the talent around. The men's basketball committee finally figured this out this past year. And with eight predetermined sites for baseball regionals, this should be even easier.
By the way, we also learned the seven-team bracket is here to stay for at least one more year. Division III baseball isn't eligible for a 56th playoff team until 2012.