| School | Location | Conf. | Head Coach |
|---|
| Augustana Vikings | Rock Island, IL | CCIW | Greg Wallace (Augustana '88) |
| Aurora Spartans | Aurora, IL | NATHC | Shaun Neitzel (William Penn '95) |
| Benedictine Eagles | Lisle, IL | NATHC | John Ostrowski (Lewis '70) |
| Blackburn Beavers | Carlinville, IL | SLIAC | Mike Neal (Illinois Wesleyan '89) |
| Buena Vista Beavers | Storm Lake, IA | IIAC | Steve Eddie (Iowa '93) |
| Carthage Red Men | Kenosha, WI | CCIW | Augie Schmidt IV (New Orleans) |
| Central Dutch | Pella, IA | IIAC | Adam Stevens (Morningside '01) |
| Chicago Maroons | Chicago, IL | IND | Brian Baldea (North Park '76) |
| Clarke Crusaders | Dubuque, IA | IND | Chad Harris (North Arkansas College '01) |
| Coe Kohawks | Cedar Rapids, IA | IIAC | Steve Cook (Allegheny '93) |
| Concordia (Ill.) Cougars | River Forest, IL | NATHC | Spiro Lempesis (St. Mary's (Minn.)) |
| Concordia (Wis.) Falcons | Mequon, WI | NATHC | Val Keiper |
| Cornell Rams | Mount Vernon, IA | IIAC | Frank Fishler (UW-La Crosse '92) |
| Dominican Stars | River Forest, IL | NATHC | Terry Casey (Dominican '97) |
| Dubuque Spartans | Dubuque, IA | IIAC | Shane Schellsmidt (Dubuque) |
| Edgewood Eagles | Madison, WI | NATHC | Al Brisack |
| Elmhurst Bluejays | Elmhurst, IL | CCIW | Joel Southern (Augustana '94) |
| Eureka Red Devils | Eureka, IL | SLIAC | Mike Mcdonald (Bradley '69) |
| Fontbonne Griffins | St. Louis, MO | SLIAC | Ryan Good (Webster) |
| Greenville Panthers | Greenville, IL | SLIAC | Lynn Carlson (Greenville '93) |
| Illinois Wesleyan Titans | Bloomington, IL | CCIW | Dennis Martel (Maine '84) |
| Lakeland Muskies | Sheboygan, WI | NATHC | Chris Thousand (Lakeland '02) |
| Loras Duhawks | Dubuque, IA | IIAC | Carl Tebon (Mount Senario '89) |
| Luther Norse | Decorah, IA | IIAC | Brian Gillogly (Luther) |
| MacMurray Highlanders | Jacksonville, IL | SLIAC | Kevin Vest |
| Maranatha Baptist Crusaders | Watertown, WI | NATHC | Phil Price (Maranatha Baptist '95) |
| Marian Sabres | Fond du Lac, WI | NATHC | Jason Bartlet (Lakeland) |
| Maryville (Mo.) Saints | Saint Louis, MO | SLIAC | Mike Sigler |
| Millikin Big Blue | Decatur, IL | CCIW | Josh Manning (MacMurray '98) |
| Milwaukee Engineering Raiders | Milwaukee, WI | NATHC | Troy Doering (Wisconsin-Milwaukee) |
| Nebraska Wesleyan Prairie Wolves | Lincoln, NE | IND | Bill Fagler (Nebraska Lincoln '71) |
| North Central Cardinals | Naperville, IL | CCIW | John Fitzgerald |
| North Park Vikings | Chicago, IL | CCIW | Luke Johnson (Elmhurst) |
| Principia Panthers | Elsah, IL | SLIAC | Pete Paciorek (Cal State LA '04) |
| Rockford Regents | Rockford, IL | NATHC | Bob Koopmann |
| Simpson Storm | Indianola, IA | IIAC | Ben Blake (Simpson '98) |
| Wartburg Knights | Waverly, IA | IIAC | Joel Holst (Coe '85) |
| Washington U. Bears | Saint Louis, MO | UAA | Ric Lessman (Harris Teachers College '60) |
| Webster Gorloks | St. Louis, MO | SLIAC | Bill Kurich (Wartburg) |
| Westminster (Mo.) Blue Jays | Fulton, MO | SLIAC | Scott Pritchard (UW-Stevens Point '93) |
| Wheaton (Ill.) Thunder | Wheaton, IL | CCIW | Bobby Elder (Oral Roberts '85) |
| Wisconsin Lutheran Warriors | Milwaukee, WI | NATHC | Brook Smith (Wisconsin Lutheran '98) |