| School | Location | Conf. | Head Coach |
|---|
| Albright Lions | Reading, PA | MACC | Jeff Feiler (Wake Forest '92) |
| Alvernia Crusaders | Reading, PA | MACC | Yogi Lutz |
| Arcadia Knights | Glenside, PA | MACC | Brian Pugh (Maine '01) |
| Baptist Bible Defenders | Clarks Summit, PA | CSAC | Justin Cook (Bible Baptist '06) |
| Centenary Cyclones | Hackettstown, NJ | CSAC | Scott Kushner (Swarthmore '02) |
| Delaware Valley Aggies | Doylestown, PA | MACF | Bob Altieri (Delaware Valley '92) |
| DeSales Bulldogs | Center Valley, PA | MACF | Tim Neiman |
| Dickinson Red Devils | Carlisle, PA | CC | Craig Hanson (Middlebury '03) |
| Drew Rangers | Madison, NJ | LAND | Vincent Masco (Trenton State '71) |
| Eastern Eagles | St. Davids, PA | MACF | Matt Midkiff (Wilkes '05) |
| Elizabethtown Blue Jays | Elizabethtown, PA | MACC | Cliff Smith (Brandeis '01) |
| FDU-Florham Devils | Madison, NJ | MACF | Andy Paulus (FDU-Madison '96) |
| Franklin and Marshall Diplomats | Lancaster, PA | CC | Adam Taylor (Randolph-Macon '99) |
| Frostburg State Bobcats | Frostburg, MD | AMCC | Guy Robertson (Elon '99) |
| Gettysburg Bullets | Gettysburg, PA | CC | John Campo (Delaware '77) |
| Gwynedd-Mercy Griffins | Gwynedd Valley, PA | CSAC | Paul Murphy (St. Joseph's, Pa. '92) |
| Haverford Fords | Haverford, PA | CC | Dave Beccaria (Johns Hopkins '96) |
| Hilbert Hawks | Hamburg, NY | AMCC | Jonathan Musialowsk (Virginia Tech '04) |
| Immaculata Mighty Macs | Immaculata, PA | CSAC | Patrick Swift (Chowan '05) |
| Johns Hopkins Blue Jays | Baltimore, MD | CC | Bob Babb (Johns Hopkins '77) |
| Juniata Eagles | Huntingdon, PA | LAND | Tom Gibboney (Juniata '78) |
| Kean Cougars | Union, NJ | NJAC | Neil Ioviero (Rutgers '94) |
| Keystone Giants | La Plume, PA | CSAC | Jamie Schevchik (East Stroudsburg) |
| King's Monarchs | Wilkes-Barre, PA | MACF | Jerry Greeley (East Stroudsburg '89) |
| La Roche Redhawks | Pittsburgh, PA | AMCC | Chase Rowe (United States Sports Academy '08) |
| Lancaster Bible Chargers | Lancaster, PA | IND | Not available |
| Lebanon Valley Flying Dutchmen | Annville, PA | MACC | Keith Evans (California (PA) '90) |
| Manhattanville Valiants | Purchase, NY | MACF | Jeff Caulfield (Cortland State '00) |
| Marywood Pacers | Scranton, PA | CSAC | Jerry Davis (Mansfield '78) |
| McDaniel Green Terror | Westminster, MD | CC | Dave Seibert (Western Maryland '78) |
| Medaille Mavericks | Buffalo, NY | AMCC | Paul J. Smaldone (Toledo) |
| Messiah Falcons | Grantham, PA | MACC | Bryan Engle (Messiah '03) |
| Misericordia Cougars | Dallas, PA | MACF | Josh Tehonica |
| Montclair State Red Hawks | Upper Montclair, NJ | NJAC | Norm Schoenig (Montclair State '72) |
| Moravian Greyhounds | Bethlehem, PA | LAND | Paul Engelhardt (Pittsburgh '96) |
| Mount Aloysius Mounties | Cresson, PA | AMCC | Kevin Kime (Walsh) |
| Muhlenberg Mules | Allentown, PA | CC | Corey Goff (Susquehanna '95) |
| Neumann Knights | Aston, PA | CSAC | John Fleming |
| New Jersey Lions | Ewing, NJ | NJAC | Dean Glus |
| New Jersey City Gothic Knights | Jersey City, NJ | NJAC | Jonathan Thomas (New Jersey City '05) |
| Penn State-Abington Nittany Lions | Abington, PA | NEAC | Joe Pavlow (Rutgers Camden '97) |
| Penn State-Altoona Lions | Altoona, PA | AMCC | Joe Piotti |
| Penn State-Behrend Lions | Erie, PA | AMCC | Paul Benim (Penn State Behrend) |
| Penn State-Berks Nittany Lions | Reading, PA | NEAC | Steve Hart (Millersville '99) |
| Penn State-Harrisburg Lions | Middletown, PA | NEAC | Jim Tetkoskie (Penn State '92) |
| Philadelphia Bible Crimson Eagles | Langhorne, PA | CSAC | Paul K. Johnson (Drexel '92) |
| Pitt-Bradford Panthers | Bradford, PA | AMCC | Bret Butler (Baldwin-Wallace) |
| Pitt-Greensburg Bobcats | Greensburg, PA | AMCC | Adam Jack (Waynesburg '99) |
| Ramapo Roadrunners | Mahwah, NJ | NJAC | Rich Martin (Brooklyn '82) |
| Richard Stockton Ospreys | Pomona, NJ | NJAC | Marty Kavanagh |
| Rowan Profs | Glassboro, NJ | NJAC | Juan Ranero (Florida State '89) |
| Rutgers-Camden Scarlet Raptors | Camden, NJ | NJAC | John Wink (Virginia Wesleyan '94) |
| Rutgers-Newark Raiders | Newark, NJ | NJAC | Mark Rizzi (Rutgers '86) |
| Scranton Royals | Scranton, PA | LAND | Mike Bartoletti (Robert Morris '85) |
| Susquehanna Crusaders | Selinsgrove, PA | LAND | Denny Bowers (Susquehanna) |
| Swarthmore Garnet | Swarthmore, PA | CC | Stan Exeter (Lafayette '92) |
| Ursinus Bears | Collegeville, PA | CC | Brian Thomas |
| Washington College Shoremen | Chestertown, MD | CC | Al Streelman (Washington College '69) |
| Widener Pride | Chester, PA | MACC | Steve Carcarey (Montgomery County CC '91) |
| Wilkes Colonels | Wilkes-Barre, PA | MACF | Joesph Folek (Wilkes '88) |
| William Paterson Pioneers | Wayne, NJ | NJAC | Mike Lauterhahn |
