| School | Location | Conf. | Head Coach |
|---|
| Adrian Bulldogs | Adrian, MI | MIAA | Craig Rainey (Adrian '88) |
| Albion Britons | Albion, MI | MIAA | Scott Carden (Bowling Green '98) |
| Allegheny Gators | Meadville, PA | NCAC | Kelly Swiney (Allegheny '99) |
| Alma Scots | Alma, MI | MIAA | Judd Folske (Ferris State University) |
| Anderson Ravens | Anderson, IN | HCAC | Don Brandon (Anderson '63) |
| Baldwin-Wallace Yellow Jackets | Berea, OH | OAC | Robert Fisher (Baldwin-Wallace '64) |
| Bethany Bison | Bethany, WV | PrAC | Rick Carver (Maryville) |
| Bluffton Beavers | Bluffton, OH | HCAC | James Grandey (Muskingum '99) |
| Calvin Knights | Grand Rapids, MI | MIAA | John Sparks (Grove City '95) |
| Capital Crusaders | Columbus, OH | OAC | Greg Weyrich (Capital '84) |
| Case Western Reserve Spartans | Cleveland, OH | UAA | Matt Englander (Wooster '02) |
| Defiance Yellow Jackets | Defiance, OH | HCAC | Derek Woodley (Minnesota State-Mankato '95) |
| Denison Big Red | Granville, OH | NCAC | Mike Clark (Cortland State '02) |
| DePauw Tigers | Greencastle, IN | SCAC | Jake Martin (Wabash '03) |
| Earlham Quakers | Richmond, IN | NCAC | John Cate |
| Finlandia Lions | Hancock, MI | IND | Matt Farrell (UW-Eau Claire '98) |
| Franciscan (Ohio) Barons | Steubenville, OH | AMCC | Robert Marrow (Rio Grande) |
| Franklin Grizzlies | Franklin, IN | HCAC | Lance Marshall (Elmhurst '93) |
| Geneva Golden Tornadoes | Beaver Falls, PA | PrAC | Alan Sumner (Geneva '85) |
| Grove City Wolverines | Grove City, PA | PrAC | Rob Skaricich (Hiram '91) |
| Hanover Panthers | Hanover, IN | HCAC | Shayne Stock (Southern Indiana '97) |
| Heidelberg Student Princes | Tiffin, OH | OAC | Matt Palm (Wooster) |
| Hiram Terriers | Hiram, OH | NCAC | Howard Jenter (Hiram '85) |
| Hope Flying Dutchmen | Holland, MI | MIAA | Stu Fritz (Wartburg '88) |
| John Carroll Blue Streaks | University Heights, OH | OAC | Marc Thibeault (John Carroll '98) |
| Kalamazoo Hornets | Kalamazoo, MI | MIAA | Matt Rix (Kalamazoo '00) |
| Kenyon Lords | Gambier, OH | NCAC | Matt Burdette (Wooster) |
| Manchester Spartans | North Manchester, IN | HCAC | Rick Espeset (Gustavus Adolphus) |
| Marietta Pioneers | Marietta, OH | OAC | Brian Brewer (Marietta '93) |
| Mount St. Joseph Lions | Cincinnati, OH | HCAC | Chuck Murray (Northern Kentucky) |
| Mount Union Purple Raiders | Alliance, OH | OAC | Paul Hesse (Kent State '82) |
| Muskingum Muskies | New Concord, OH | OAC | Gregg Thompson (Delaware '92) |
| Oberlin Yeomen | Oberlin, OH | NCAC | Eric Lahetta (Bowling Green '92) |
| Ohio Northern Polar Bears | Ada, OH | OAC | Justin Bergman (Franklin '01) |
| Ohio Wesleyan Battling Bishops | Delaware, OH | NCAC | Tyler Mott |
| Olivet Comets | Olivet, MI | MIAA | Ted Mahan (Michigan '77) |
| Otterbein Cardinals | Westerville, OH | OAC | George Powell (Ohio Wesleyan) |
| Rose-Hulman Engineers | Terre Haute, IN | HCAC | Jeff Jenkins (Ohio Northern '81) |
| St. Vincent Bearcats | Latrobe, PA | PrAC | Mick Janosko (Point Park College '90) |
| Thiel Tomcats | Greenville, PA | PrAC | Joe Schaly (Marietta '86) |
| Thomas More Saints | Crestview Hills, KY | PrAC | Jeff Hetzer (Northern Kentucky '98) |
| Transylvania Pioneers | Lexington, KY | HCAC | Chris Campbell (Transylvania '00) |
| Trine Thunder | Angola, IN | MIAA | Greg Perschke (New Orleans) |
| Wabash Little Giants | Crawfordsville, IN | NCAC | Cory Stevens (North Central (Ill.) '00) |
| Washington and Jefferson Presidents | Washington, PA | PrAC | Jeff Mountain (Allegheny '00) |
| Waynesburg Yellow Jackets | Waynesburg, PA | PrAC | Mike Humiston (Weber State '81) |
| Westminster (Pa.) Titans | New Wilmington, PA | PrAC | Carmen Nocera |
| Wilmington Quakers | Wilmington, OH | OAC | Tony Haley |
| Wittenberg Tigers | Springfield, OH | NCAC | Jay Lewis (Wittenberg '94) |
| Wooster Scots | Wooster, OH | NCAC | Tim Pettorini (Bowling Green '73) |
